Stay up to date on upcoming events, deadlines, news, and more by signing up for our newsletters.
At a recent roundtable hosted at the NYU Leslie Entrepreneurial Institute, we had the opportunity to sit down with Amanda Herson of Founder Collective. The conversation covered everything from how early-stage investors actually make decisions to what founders consistently get wrong when building and fundraising.
The takeaway was simple but sharp: building a company is less about getting it right every step of the way and more about judgment. And most of that judgment shows up long before a term sheet ever does.
1. Time is the only real constraint
Founder Collective makes roughly 20-40 investments per year with a small team. That alone reframes how founders should think about fundraising. Every meeting, every deck, every intro competes for one scarce resource: investor time.
That’s why Amanda emphasized not “over-iterating” on a pitch. At some point, you have to get it in front of people. Precision matters, but speed and clarity matter more.
The best founders don’t wait for perfection. They get to signal quickly.
2. Financial models are not about the numbers
One of the more counterintuitive insights was around financial models. Investors are not looking for perfectly accurate projections. They’re looking for evidence that the founder understands the economics of the business.
Can you explain where revenue comes from? What drives margins? What breaks as you scale?
If the model answers those questions, it works. If it doesn’t, no amount of spreadsheet complexity will save it.
3. Sales is the fastest path to truth
A recurring theme throughout the conversation was sales. Not as a function, but as a founder skill.
The fastest-moving founders are the ones selling something early. Not because they need revenue immediately, but because sales forces clarity. It exposes whether the product actually solves a problem and whether anyone cares enough to pay.
There’s also a sequencing mistake many founders make. They either stop doing sales too early, or they hold onto it for too long. Early on, founders should own it completely. Later, they need to transition it deliberately.
But in the beginning, there is no substitute. If you can’t sell it, nothing else matters.
4. Product is easier. Distribution is not.
AI has lowered the barrier to building product, but it hasn’t made distribution any easier. If anything, it’s made differentiation harder.
Amanda framed this clearly: the playing field for building is leveling, but the playing field for getting attention is not. That’s where moats actually start to matter. Regulatory advantages. Proprietary data. Unique distribution channels. These are the things that compound over time.
The question investors are asking is not just “what did you build,” but “why are you the one who wins.”
5. Fundraising is closer to dating than finance
One of the more memorable analogies was around founder-investor fit.
Finding the right investor is less like running a process and more like finding a partner. Timing, chemistry, context, even mood all play a role. Two identical pitches can land very differently depending on the moment.
Warm introductions help, but they’re not everything. And mutual connections don’t guarantee alignment. At the end of the day, you’re choosing someone you’ll be tied to for years. The comparison to long-term relationships is not an exaggeration.
6. Founder dynamics are make-or-break
If there was one point that stood out most, it was this: one of the biggest reasons companies fail is founder breakups.
The bar for choosing a cofounder should be extremely high. Amanda described it simply. You should know your cofounder well enough to know their coffee order.
That level of familiarity reflects trust. And trust is what holds up when things inevitably get difficult. Interestingly, she also noted that being a solo founder can be preferable to the wrong partnership. You can always hire talent. You cannot fix a broken founding relationship.
7. Hiring: default to scrappy
Early hiring should optimize for attitude over aptitude.
Perfect resumes are less important than people who are willing to figure things out. Especially in the early days, ambiguity is constant. You need people who lean into it, not people who wait for structure.
The same logic applies to sales hires. Even the best salesperson cannot compensate for a weak product. If churn is high, the problem is rarely the sales team.
8. The market sets the rules
Check sizes at Founder Collective range from roughly $700k to $2.5m, but Amanda made it clear that pricing is highly contextual. Founder experience, market conditions, and category dynamics all play a role.
The key insight was that “goalposts are always moving.” Founders need to read the market. What worked six months ago may not work today.
Some founders raise once and never again. Others build for multiple rounds. There is no fixed path, only what makes sense given the moment.
Final thought
The most consistent thread across the conversation was this: great founders are not just builders. They are translators. They translate a product into a story. A vision into something investors believe. A hypothesis into something customers will pay for.
And the fastest way to get there is not more theory. It’s action.
Go build. Then go sell.
