Finding the right initial target customer is one of the most critical decisions a startup can make—and one we see founders struggle with regularly. While it's tempting to cast a wide net and serve the largest possible market, successful startups begin by focusing on specific, well-defined customer segments who urgently need their solution.

The key to identifying your initial target customer lies in finding your "innovators"—those who not only need a solution but need it so urgently that they'll try something new from an unknown startup. These customers are experiencing enough pain that they're actively seeking solutions and willing to take a chance on an imperfect one.

A common mistake founders make is trying to appeal to too broad a market initially. Rather than targeting a large market with diverse needs—where you'll likely meet lukewarm interest—it's better to focus on a smaller market with an intense need. As Airbnb's Brian Chesky famously said: "It's better to have 100 people who love you than a million people who just sort of like you."

It's better to have 100 people who love you than a million people who just sort of like you. ~ Brian Chesky

Direct customer discovery interviews are essential for validating your assumptions—while surveys and secondary research have their place, nothing beats talking to real people and understanding their workflows. If your initial assumptions prove wrong, you can quickly pivot and test different market segments until you find the right "problem-solution" fit.

When evaluating potential target segments for customer discovery, consider these key factors:

• Problem intensity: How painful is the problem for this group? The more acute the pain point, the more likely they'll be open to try a new solution. If the problem is truly significant, they're probably already searching for solutions and will eagerly discuss their challenges and previous attempts to solve them.
• Accessibility: Can you easily reach these users for interviews and feedback? You need direct contact with customers to test your assumptions. If it's difficult to reach them for discovery interviews now, it will likely be even harder to reach them for sales later.
• Decision-making ability: Do they have the authority to actually buy/use your product if your hypothesis proves correct? Learn this by asking how they've solved similar problems before—who evaluated solutions, who approved purchases, and what their buying process looked like. These insights will reveal whether you're talking to true decision-makers.

Keep in mind that your initial target customer needn’t be your permanent market. Success comes from finding a customer group that can quickly help you test your assumptions, enabling you to either expand your current approach or pivot to explore new segments.

Many successful companies started by dominating a niche before expanding, including:

• Brooklinen: Initially targeted young urban professionals who sought high-quality, affordable bedding and preferred shopping online. This focused market helped them perfect their product and build a loyal following before expanding to other home goods categories and customer segments.
• Instacart: Built a marketplace for grocery delivery by targeting busy urban professionals who valued convenience and would pay premium prices for delivery service. This focused approach helped Instacart build the critical mass of customers and shoppers needed in each area, while perfecting their operations in high-demand locations before expanding to broader demographics and suburban regions.
• Notion: Initially targeted tech-savvy individuals and small startups frustrated by the information silos created by using separate tools for note-taking, project management, and collaboration. This focused audience quickly adopted new solutions and made fast decisions, which drove word-of-mouth growth. This allowed Notion to refine its product before tackling the complex needs and longer sales cycles of large enterprises.
• Pepper: Targeted petite women with small cup sizes who struggled to find well-fitting bras. This focused approach allowed them to deeply understand and serve an underserved market before expanding into more diverse body types and product categories.
• Slack: Entered the workplace communication scene by targeting tech-savvy professionals in startups and small teams who valued real-time messaging and were eager to try new productivity tools. This focused approach enabled rapid adoption, quick feedback cycles, and product refinement, building a strong foundation of advocates before expanding into larger organizations.

Selecting your initial target customer segment requires forming testable hypotheses about specific people in defined market segments. These hypotheses should consider factors like problem intensity, accessibility, and decision-making speed. Start narrow and focused, but don't worry if your first target market assumptions prove wrong. What matters is quickly validating or invalidating these assumptions through direct customer interviews. With an experimental mindset and willingness to pivot, you'll find your way to true product-market fit. Only after achieving this should you expand—building from strength, just as successful companies above have done using this methodical approach to build thriving businesses.

Need help with identifying your venture's initial target customer? Come in for coaching! Sign up here.