When Colin Beirne was twenty-five, he called his father to talk through a decision that, from the outside, looked like it had an obvious answer.
He was four years into Lehman Brothers and doing well. Lehman had been in business for a hundred and twenty-five years, so if he stayed there was a promotion ahead of him and a career after that. Then a hedge fund he’d barely heard of called Two Sigma got in touch, a three-year-old outfit of about sixty people where everyone came to work in shorts.
“It definitely felt like the absolute safest path in my career,” he said of staying at Lehman. He went to the hedge fund instead, and three years later Lehman collapsed. Telling the story to a room full of founders, he refused to dress it up as foresight. “Obviously it worked out. I was pretty lucky. I wasn’t smart about it.”
That honesty set the tone for the whole ninety minutes. Beirne is now Founding Partner at Deviation Capital, which spun out of Two Sigma in April of this year carrying the entire Two Sigma Ventures team and portfolio with it, and when he sat down with the Leslie Founders on Monday evening he talked less about what he’s gotten right than about how he decides at all.
He talked his way into the job
Seven years into Two Sigma, Beirne stood up at a company offsite at the Crosby Hotel. He told the room the firm should start a venture capital business.
The argument came out of the work he was already doing. Two Sigma’s thesis about markets was simple enough. There is too much data for any human to hold in their head, so you build models and let the computers decide. Beirne thought that was about to stop being a hedge fund idea. It was becoming how every industry worked. He also thought New York was starting to feel like the San Francisco he remembered.
They said yes at a cocktail party that same night. The next morning he was a venture capitalist with no portfolio and no team. Fourteen years later the business had four funds and roughly two billion dollars under management.
Vision, agility, magnetism
Deviation invests early, writing checks from about half a million dollars up to fifteen million. Six months in, they’ve made six investments. Very little of the decision is now about the business.
“We used to debate a lot more than we do now about competition or business model, even market size,” he said. “Now we almost only select for founder.” He named three qualities.
The first is vision. He means taste and judgment about what to build, which has become the scarce thing precisely because building has become easy.
The second is agility. You can wake up believing you have a great product and discover by lunchtime that someone built the same thing over a weekend. What matters is how fast you turn your whole team around.
The third he calls magnetism. Can you attract people better than you, and can you attract capital? That second half matters more than it used to, because the ambitious things are expensive again. Deviation’s first investment was a seed round that raised three hundred million dollars, for a robotics company building physical hardware.
He was unusually candid about who his money is wrong for. His fund will back around thirty companies. Roughly half will be worth nothing. Another seven to ten sell for something modest. Essentially all of the return comes from one, two, or three companies worth fifty or a hundred times what he paid. “All of you should think hard about whether you want to take that kind of capital,” he told the founders, “because it generally increases the risk factor of your company.”
Getting in the door
They invest in less than half a percent of what crosses their desk, roughly one in two hundred.
Warm introductions help, and he reads anything that comes from a degree of separation. But relying only on your network keeps you inside your network. The founder he most doesn’t want to miss sits somewhere like Romania, knows no investors at all, and has all three qualities anyway.
What earns a reply to a cold email is evidence that a person wrote it. A subject line or an opening sentence that’s specific, or funny, or shows they looked him up. What kills it is anything mass-produced. He gets the AI-generated version constantly now: I saw you invested in WHOOP, so you should invest in this.
Founder-market fit
Underneath it all he asks one question. Is this particular person among the handful on earth who ought to be solving this particular problem?
His favorite illustration is WHOOP. Will Ahmed started it out of a Harvard dorm room while he was captain of the squash team. The question this kid asked was why we know more about what’s happening inside a car engine than inside our own bodies. At the time, the best thing on the market was a Fitbit you kept in your pocket, and accidentally it ended up in the washing machine. “That’s kind of all it took to get the meeting,” Beirne said. “It makes sense. It’s a good fit.”
Which leads to the pitch advice he clearly wishes more founders would take. Decks are full of product and empty of people. “I don’t want to have to ask what’s your motivation, why are you doing this, and why are you the perfect person to do it.” He wants it in the deck, because the deck earns the meeting. Any idea can be copied in a weekend. The person is the part that can’t be.
That is also most of what defensibility means now. Remote, a portfolio company, scrapped an entire HR software suite nine months ago to focus on something harder. The durable thing was never the software. It was years of unglamorous country-by-country legal work that nobody can rebuild with an agent.
The North Star
He’s changed his mind about what a good founder looks like. Early in his career he liked the ones who absorbed feedback and adjusted. Now he wants closer to the opposite. “I really like founders who are like, I have a North Star, and it is very, very hard to knock me off of it.” He isn’t describing stubbornness, since you take investors partly for the advice. But he does want people who are hard to move off a path they’ve chosen on purpose.
He told a story about a founder who brought a major decision to his twelve-person executive team. All twelve voted for plan A. The founder listened to every one of them, thanked them, and chose plan B. Two years later the entire team was glad he had.
Asked what he’s learned from the founders he’s backed, he didn’t hesitate. Speed. “I’m a bit of a cautious decision maker at times, and the very best founders are usually not like that.” They decide quickly, then bring everyone with them, including the twelve people they just overruled.
After the money
If an investor sits on your board, talk to them weekly. Keep it informal enough to involve texts and the occasional Friday night call. If you have no board, send updates anyway, monthly if you can manage it.
The best updates go past metrics and headcount. They cover what’s genuinely on your mind and what’s keeping you up at night, and they end with specific asks. One of his founders opens every update with a line quoted from a customer. Beirne noted that this is shrewd, particularly in the months when the rest of the letter is bad news.
And if he passes on you, it isn’t final. “I love being wrong. I love it when founders prove me wrong.” The thing that does it is expansion. A customer who was paying eighteen thousand dollars when he said no is now paying ninety, with three hundred on the table for next year. He isn’t looking for a long customer list. He wants a small number of people who can no longer imagine working without you.
Which is roughly what he was looking for in himself at twenty-five, standing in front of a safe job at a hundred-and-twenty-five-year-old bank and choosing the three-year-old company in shorts.